FishQualityBonus

In base game, recipes that consume a whole fish (Fish 'n' Bread, the fish mead bases) output the same amount whether you spent a quality-1 perch or a quality-4 anglerfish. This is totally inconsistent with how Raw Fish behaves.

This mod adjusts the behavior in the following ways:

• Bigger fish make more. Output scales with the fish's quality, using the same formula the game already applies to Raw Fish. For example, using a quality-5 fish makes 13 instead of 1.
• Rarer fish make more. Each species' flat +0/+1/+2 tier applies on top, read out of the game at load rather than hard-coded. Fish 'n' Bread takes a +2 species, so that quality-5 craft actually lands at 15 meals.
• Fish of different sizes can be combined. The base game refuses to craft when your fish qualities don't match (e.g. two trollfish of different sizes can't brew a mead that needs two, even though the ingredient list says you have enough). This fixes that, and the output is based on the average size of what you spent.
• Choose which fish size to prioritize. Configuration options include which fish gets consumed first (e.g. prioritize higher or lower quality in your inventory when crafting).

Most of the above parameters are configurable, including a master switch that restores vanilla exactly.

Why I made this

Hello! I created this mod to fix a nitpick that felt, in my opinion, like an oversight, which is simply this: fishing recipes should reward you for the quality of the fish.

In Valheim, Raw Fish, prepared from an actual caught fish, are multiplied in value based on the quality of the fish caught. If I catch a big, quality-5 tuna, I can actually prepare 14 "raw fish" from that single tuna.

However, this does not apply to any recipes that consume a whole fish, which in my opinion completely wastes the higher quality fish in those recipes.

Since recipes like Fish 'n' Bread, currently one of the best stamina foods in the game, take a whole fish, the player is effectively penalized for using the better quality anglerfish in that recipe. (Making the joy of actually hooking a high-quality fish not worth the stamina spent to reel it in)

This mod adjusts it by applying the same raw fish computation formula to other whole-fish recipes, as well! And while I was in the code, I decided to fix the mixed-quality-crafting issue as well.

Behavior

What a recipe that normally makes 1 gives you, at the default settings:

The formula behind that:

sizeBonus = floor( (averageQuality - 1) * amount * BonusPerQualityLevel )
output    = amount + sizeBonus + speciesBonus

amount is what the recipe normally makes. averageQuality is the mean quality of the fish spent, which is just the fish's own quality when they're all the same size.

BonusPerQualityLevel is configurable and defaults to 3, matching the game's own Raw Fish behavior.

speciesBonus is the game's +0/+1/+2 tier for the species — see Raw Fish. Like vanilla, it's flat: even a small quality-1 anglerfish still earns its +2. Also configurable.

Which fish gets eaten

Vanilla spends whichever fish you picked up first, and it doesn't even matter where it sits in your inventory ( effectively random). This mod picks on purpose, smallest or largest first, via FishToSpend.

Fish of different sizes

Vanilla won't let you craft when your fish don't match. It checks your biggest single-size stack instead of your total, so two trollfish of different sizes can't brew a Troll Endurance mead that needs two. Confusingly, the ingredient list shows 2 of 2 in white, and the Craft button stays grayed out with nothing explaining why. This is really only a problem that affects fish recipes, as every other crafting material has only one quality level.

This mod allows the craft and pays out on the average of what you spent. Two trollfish in a mead base that normally makes 1:

Set AllowMixedQualities to false to keep vanilla's rules and disallow the craft in these mixed cases.

Which recipes qualify

This should be safe to pick up new recipes added via updates and mods, because the mod loads recipes at runtime and matches via ItemType.Fish. A recipe qualifies only if all of these are met:

1. it is not flagged m_requireOnlyOneIngredient (currently only FishRaw uses this),
2. its output is not equipment, by the game's own IsEquipable() check,
3. it requires exactly one fish species; scaling when more than one is involved feels messy,
4. it passes the IncludeMeadRecipes and ExcludedRecipes configurable settings.

In vanilla and with default config, that means this mod applies to Fish 'n' Bread plus three mead bases: MeadBaseBugRepellent, MeadBaseStrength, and MeadBaseSwimmer.

Config

Written to BepInEx/config/pandincus.fishqualitybonus.cfg on first run, and editable in-game with ConfigurationManager (F1). Changes apply immediately.

Multiplayer

This is a client-side mod. The crafting result is computed locally and synced like any other inventory change, so the server does not need the mod. But everyone who crafts and wants this behavior needs it installed, or identical ingredients will give different results for different players.

Developing

Build instructions, tooling and tests are in the repo README.

This is my first mod! This was built through a combination of code-diving, wiki reading, and usage of Claude Code. Note that even though I used Claude Code to develop the code changes, I've reviewed each line of code, applied manual refactors, and have heavily rewritten code comments.

Please feel free to offer feedback and I would happily accept community contributions.

Future Work

This isn't perfect. If we get recipes in the future that involve more than one whole fish, I'll need to revisit this mod to eliminate the single-ingredient requirement. Further, I don't love that we get the fish-recipe-output multiplied, but don't also consume more of the other ingredients. Using Fish 'n' Bread as an example, additional bread dough should probably also be consumed, even though we've got 'more' fish to go around. The latter issue is one I will consider addressing in an upcoming release.

With Valheim 1.0 coming out soon, I'm not sure what will change that might impact this mod. Perhaps the devs have already fixed this issue! Or perhaps they'll add more fishing recipes and we'll want to test that this continues to work. But since I wrote this mod to use it, I will revisit and update in the near future.

See the CHANGELOG for release notes. On Thunderstore it is also the Changelog tab on this package's page.